Which Tailgate Stencil???

I've used Rustolium gloss spray paint with decent results. I use a light coat of spray adhesive on the back of the stencil to keep it tight, and spray a couple light coats a few minutes apart. This left a slightly soft edge similar to the way they came new.
I have also used automotive base coat, then cleared the whole panel. That was the for an "over-restoration". I don't really like the wet-look gloss on vintage Jeeps.
-Donny